Rated 4 out of 5
Pensil 11 DIY speaker kit (From: £480.00 inc VAT)
Well I think it’s about time I submitted this review, having received the kit back in May 2017 after seeing you guys at the Bristol Show and ordering soon after! In my defence I didn’t start building the speakers till December, partly because I thought it was going to be a big job and also because I wanted to find the time to tackle it properly.
The Build:
As a complete newcomer to this (and many decades since I tackled any DIY project at all - I had to go buy all the clamps and tools!) the build was actually considerably easier than I imagined and there isn’t really much to say about it, although I will offer a few tips here for those brand new to this like me.
Stefan advices a dummy run through without glue, and I second that, make that three dummy runs for me! The last one even with the glue bottle in my hand pretending to glue so I knew exactly how much time I would actually have! The final proper glueing run was a doddle and was all finished in no time. Secondly I would take longer on smoothing down the plywood edges, and be far more careful about positioning the top plate so it is flush with the side panels at that point in the build. This birch ply has a beautiful finish, and had I known how well it would take to my polishing process (gleaned from DIYAUDIO forum) I would have been far more careful.
I used a scraper (not sandpaper which just keeps raising the nap) to finish the panels, and as the top ply layer is already a finish in itself this only took a few goes with this amazing tool, just removing the finest of sawdust layer whilst burnishing the wood laying down any remaining nap. Four coats of well rubbed in finishing wax (this ply is very thirsty and drinks it!) and the results I must say are far better than I expected. The wax says leave for 30 minutes between applying and buffing up, but longer is better and it still continues drying out after 24 hours or more.
When it comes time to insert your drive units don’t even attempt this before you have ether drilled the retaining holes all the way through or at least reamed the indents provided out a bit with a thin screwdriver to make screwing the bolts in easier. I made the mistake of simply popping in the drivers and trying to screw them down, bad move. The ply is as hard as nails and exerting the force required to get the bolts home properly whilst trying to avoid slipping and taking out a driver cone in the process is massively nerve racking.
Also, Mark Audio needs to either toughen up the ABS surround for these drivers or minimise the depth of the rubber seal provided (as Stefan has advised) because I easily distorted the driver surround by over tightening the bolts. I don’t think this would have happened if I had drilled the holes for the bolts first, as I would have been able to feel the tightness and stopped just as they were nipped into place. No lasting problems though, the performance isn’t effected and slacking off the bolts has returned the frame to virtually it’s original shape.
The Warm up:
Slowly, slowly, not listening at all is my advice, you are warming up the drivers so you don’t want to educate your brain in how they sound until you are ready - the brain is great at this and in my opinion most burn-in effect is actually brain/ear interface acclimatisation. It seems to be recommended for Mark Audio drivers that the first 20 hours or so is bare audible and acoustic material only, gradually increasing volume each day for say 100 hours or so. I then introduced more dynamic material and left them playing to themselves at slightly less than normal listening levels for another week or so. I have a spare room so this wasn’t a problem.
Whilst this was happening I couldn’t but be astonished at the clarity even as I tried not to get drawn in to listening proper - astonishing I think I said to Stefan!
The Stuffing:
I have spent literally weeks tuning this, driving myself nuts and spending days on forums looking for advice. The best advice seems to be ’stuff to taste’ which as a scientific fellow didn’t really appeal to me. So after a long email from Stefan I had a good idea of the ideal ‘Q’ (whatever the hell that means!) amount and where to put it. I eventually filled the middle region of the cabinet in all its sections with around 400g (there’s tons of bracing to rip your skin on - my hands were shredded!) I tried to keep the stuffing of an even density and not clumped up anywhere, it’s well away from the bottom port and slightly built up at the rear of the cabinet behind but a long way from the driver.
I also damped the side cheeks with felt as the sound was still a bit ragged. Plus I damped the rear panel opposite the back of the drivers as it seemed logical - not sure this had any effect at all but the contact adhesive informs me the felt is there for good now unless I want to scrape it off with a Stanley knife!
I over stuffed first, and the sound went flat and lifeless, so this part of the build is crucial and takes time believe me. I wish I had a measurement device and the skills to understand what it was telling me, but I just have to trust these old audiophile ears. I am sure I will take some stuffing out later, once I have acclimatised myself and maybe when I have more room for them in my new home - but that’s a little way off yet.
The Sound:
This is the bit I’ve been looking forward to, after a few weeks of tweaking and stuffing and tweaking and stuffing I think I’ve got to about the optimum level playing field in which to see just what these speakers can do.
“Wow what prodigious bass” is still the first impression, but that might be because I’ve been used to various incarnations of AVI’s ADM (Active Digital Monitors) speakers for a decade or more now. These are fast active stand mount studio type monitors with tight, tight bass, and even though I had them supplemented with a subwoofer, that still obviously left a mid-bass gap just where the Pensils have plenty to offer!
Of course this is very room and position dependent, and now they are up against the wall and firing across the room, where the ADMs once stood, this surprisingly seems to have tamed the bass considerably. I’m gradually getting used to the fuller and heavier sound - and on acoustic instruments like double bass or cello I can vouch this is beautifully accurate so no complaints here. It does make you wonder what speakers some electronic tracks are mastered on though, tic tac sounds the producer obviously thought would enhance things appear randomly and overly prominent and when sub-bass just seems to appear from nowhere and then go away again for no seeming reason one wonders if these studios have proper revealing speakers or headphones to listen on?
The first thing you notice on familiar tracks is the detail that these speakers pull out of the mix is astonishing, and on well recorded material the voices especially are truly real and tangible. Like the Hi-Fi Pig review states, micro detail is everywhere apparent and digs information out of recordings you thought you knew well. Timing and rhythm is excellent and foot tapping occurs on a regular basis. I get the impression, after about 6 weeks of occasional listening a couple of hours a night, that the cones do seem to over emphasis metallic sounds (snicks and snacks in the mix do seem over prominent as mentioned above) - the reverse side of this is that acoustic recordings sound amazing and when Ben Webster appears, obviously walking in towards the mic from the rear of the room, well - it’s hairs standing up on the back of the neck time!
There’s no denying that after just over a month of casual listening these are bright speakers, not nasty, but unforgiving. I can turn up the volume right to where vocals should begin to ‘shout’ and they don’t, they stay perfectly clear, but accompanying rim shots and cymbals etc become overly dominant and drown the mix. I hear on the forum that Mark Audio drivers do just keep improving, so I’m hoping that is the case and they smooth out a little. I did worry initially that I would end up down that narrow audiophile tunnel where only a few selected well recorded albums pass muster enough to listen to - but that isn’t the case. I’ve just had an evening with Frank Zappa and the Mothers listening to their Roxy Sessions just released… loud, crazy, real, dynamic, right there in the room. If you turn it up at the beginning to listen to Frank talking then forget to turn it down for the music - wow - truly live, in the room, at volume 11!!
I tend to listen to an eclectic mix, so these speakers will never be used just to listen to a small selection of audiophile quality recordings - and I can vouch that Tom Waits, PJ Harvey, This Is the Kit, Fink (oh Fink, that voice and guitar on Perfect Darkness turned way up!!!) all sound utterly amazing and fair just as well as the darling of audio shows Diana Krall! In fact I was going through the Verve and Impulse catalogues on Qobuz the other night and got to bed in the wee small hours, I just couldn’t switch off. Billie Holiday was truly in the room with me, I could hear Sonny Stitt slow pace and reduce volume just a tad before a big blow just knocked me out with its realism - and said Diana Krall’s piano went deep, deep, deep with her breathy voice exotically intoxicating. Remarkable, honestly, remarkable. If I could have built these speakers a few years ago I would never have got rid of £12k worth of Meridian 500 series kit that never did sound as good as I knew it could - because I simply couldn’t afford the £5k upwards the hi-fi shop wanted for the speakers to match!
However, it seems after years of no speaker cables, no DAC, no interconnects (except a Toslink to connect my AVI’s to my Auralic Aries Mini) I am well and truly back into the ‘hobby’ of hi-fi upgrades again! I would say, even if they mellow with age, these speakers are what’s known in the trade as ‘revealing’. Be warned, ancillary equipment needs to be of sufficient calibre otherwise it will be found wanting. I wouldn’t treat these like a £600 set of speakers, you could quadruple that price and still not be disappointed - if they were made in 15 year aged French oak of course!
I quickly discovered my trusty Chord Mojo DAC (usually on headphone duty) gives a cleaner, fluid, less grainy edge to high frequencies compared to using the Auralic’s built-in DAC (which sounds exceptional for a built-in offering). Plus the 4mm Van Damme speaker cable I initially purchased is both heavy and restrictive compared to the old single core DNM Reson cable I had laying around from years back. The Reson is light footed and clear as a bell in comparison, and very believable across the entire frequency range, I’ll probable wire inside with it as well when I take the backs off next.
If I am to believe what these excellent drivers are telling me, and I am starting to trust what they say, then there is plenty of room for improvement as time goes on. For a start I have no idea how my amp fits into the scheme of things for example, it was a lucky buy off ebay from a guy in Vienna and it certainly looks the part and reviews well. But who knows what a nice Single End Triode valve jobbie would sound like through these speakers? They are certainly very efficient, I can’t get the Heed up above 9 o’clock on the volume control even after turning down the Chord to 1v output!
I did in fact buy this full range single driver kit to recapture just that feeling of an analogue era long gone. It was after hearing Ben Webster coming through the beautiful Mark Audio driven Pearl Acoustics Sibelius speakers. They were being fed from a Revox reel to reel tape deck into a glowing valve amp at the Bristol show last year. Ok the Pensil 11 kit isn’t quite up to that level, nor should it be at the price. But apart from custom matched MA drivers, 15 year aged French oak build and the months of tweaking it took Pearl Acoustics to perfect the sound (I bet that was the stuffing!) I feel I am closer than I ought to be considering the difference in value.
The Pluvia’s are perhaps a more modern sounding driver, perhaps a little less analogue and forgiving - but I am still astonished at the sound I am hearing - and how much I saved over a shop bought alternative by building them myself. I can’t recommend this kit highly enough, but be warned, it is the start of a slippery slope, I am already thinking about my next build!
Tim Woodward
Qobuz Sublime Plus -> Auralic Aries Mini streamer -> Chord Mojo DAC -> Heed Obelisk SI V2 -> Woodward Audio’s custom built Finlandia Speakers (that’s what I’m calling ‘em!)
View this product →
